MENTORS
  • News
  • Business
  • Self Growth
  • Mentors Collective Podcast
    • Apply As Guest
    • Listen on Spotify
    • Listen on Apple
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Register
MENTORS
  • News
  • Business
  • Self Growth
  • Mentors Collective Podcast
    • Apply As Guest
    • Listen on Spotify
    • Listen on Apple
No Result
View All Result
MENTORS
No Result
View All Result

Google, antitrust and how best to regulate big tech

Jay Feldman<span class="bp-verified-badge"></span> by Jay Feldman
October 11, 2020
in Economy
Google, antitrust and how best to regulate big tech
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

Antitrust cases over past behavior have proved mostly ineffectual. So regulators are turning their attention to forward-looking rules


ANY DAY now America’s Department of Justice (DoJ) will file a lawsuit against Google, accusing it of abusing its monopoly in an online search. It will be the first big antitrust case in technology since the DoJ went after Microsoft in 1998. Expect William Barr, the attorney-general, to flaunt this as proof that the Trump administration is uncowed by big tech.

Political posturing notwithstanding, the lawsuit will be no Google-slayer. Few states are likely to join the case. The firm’s broader advertising business will probably not be targeted. If the Microsoft trial is a guide, the ordeal will drag on for years and be distracting for Google. But it is likely to end in a forgettable settlement—even under a President Joe Biden.

Potentially more consequential tech regulation is on the boil elsewhere, however. Many policymakers see antitrust suits filed after the fact (“ex-post”) unfit for purpose in fast-moving tech markets. They are pushing for “ex-ante” rules that would, as in other industries, constrain online platforms upfront. On October 6th a Congressional committee published a 449-page report on how America should update its competition law. Days earlier a laundry list of rules to be included in the EU’s Digital Services Act, an ambitious regulatory package expected in early December, was leaked. Will these efforts be more successful than old-school competition remedies?

Start with the report, the result of a 16-month probe by the House of Representatives, led by David Cicilline, a Democrat. Despite America’s polarised politics, much of the diagnosis enjoys bipartisan support. The report “accurately portrays how Apple, Amazon, Google, and Facebook have used their monopoly power to act as gatekeepers to the marketplace”, wrote Ken Buck, echoing many fellow House Republicans.

Predictably, the two parties disagree on what to do about it. Democrats want big tech firms to separate their main line of business from other activities. For example, Amazon could no longer sell wares under its brands on its marketplace, where it allegedly gives itself preferential treatment, including better placement in search results. Republicans reject such measures as too interventionist and propose to tweak existing antitrust laws.

Amazon disputed the report’s findings. “The presumption that success can only be the result of anticompetitive behavior is simply wrong,” it said. Apple, Facebook and Alphabet, Google’s parent company, issued statements to similar effect. Still, for anything meaningful to pass in Congress, next month Democrats must win not just the presidency but also, more fancifully, a big Senate majority that would allow them to push through bold legislation even if some party moderates are not on board.

Having already tried, without much success, to change the tech giants’ behavior with antitrust probes and fines, the EU is betting on ex-ante. Its big idea is to prohibit big gatekeepers from engaging in “unfair practices”. The leaked paper lists 30 such practices, ranging from platforms favoring their own services to their refusal to work with competing ones.

If all the EU suggestions were enacted, gatekeepers would end up in a legal straitjacket. The proposals could weaken “network effects”—forces in online markets that let big firms get bigger. For instance, dominant messaging apps such as Facebook’s WhatsApp may be forced to accept messages from smaller ones. Platforms may be compelled to share data with rivals, removing a barrier to entry for newcomers.

As ever, the devil is in the details—with which the European Commission, the EU’s executive arm, is now grappling. What exactly counts as a gatekeeper? The number of users and revenue matters. But what about data assets, which are harder to measure? What data should platforms share? Interoperability between messaging apps would be welcome in some ways—as mobile providers must accept calls from rival networks. But it may harm competition between encryption methods, which interoperable apps would need to harmonize. Being too prescriptive could keep big platforms from innovating.

Eurocrats find themselves in what Mark Shmulik of Bernstein, a research firm, calls “a regulator’s dilemma”: coming up with robust rules that avoid unintended consequences. The commission’s answer is for its own experts, and perhaps a new agency, to decide on a case-by-case basis what activities are anticompetitive. Firms would have to prove they are not.

Coming up with effective rules will take time—possibly no less time than antitrust cases. But it would be a historical anomaly if tech were not to be robustly regulated, as other systemically important industries such as banking and food were before it. The public seems ready: 72% of American adults say that social-media firms have too much political power, according to a Pew poll. So are smaller tech firms, which are pursuing their own, ex-post efforts. Epic, which makes “Fortnite”, a hit video game, has sued Apple on antitrust grounds. Oracle’s crusade against Google over alleged copyright infringement, which the Supreme Court agreed to hear on October 7th, has an antitrust tinge. The techlash may be subsiding. The tech-slog has begun.■

Read More

Tags: News
Jay Feldman<span class="bp-verified-badge"></span>

Jay Feldman

I am an Osteopathic doctor with a love for business, traveling, and animals. I hope to give back to the community through empowering individuals to help others through media and business. I love learning new things and sharing them with the world. I hope you enjoy my page.

Related Posts

edit post
daxsen bank wallet
Economy

Daxsen Bank: Why Digital Banking is Your Best Option Navigating an Economic Downturn

businesses are looking for ways to protect their finances and prepare for a potential recession. One option that is...

by David Daxsen
January 20, 2023
251
edit post
Should you be self-employed? Today’s gig economy says yes!
Economy

Should you be self-employed? Today’s gig economy says yes!

Over the past 10 years, we have seen the emergence of a whole segment of work we now call...

by Mentors Collective Staff
October 29, 2022
256
edit post
Decentralization
Economy

Is Decentralization Eating the World?

Decentralization has many advantages. But the most crucial advantage of decentralization is that it gives power back to the...

by Mentors Collective Staff
August 24, 2022
255
edit post
Distribution Industry Condemns Tax Increase on American Families and Businesses
Economy

Distribution Industry Condemns Tax Increase on American Families and Businesses

All members of the U.S. Senate opposing H.R. 5376, The Inflation Reduction Act, and urging legislators to vote against the...

by Mentors Collective Staff
August 6, 2022
252
Next Post
edit post
World Coronavirus Dispatch: Tycoon running 500 hotels cautions of more job cuts

World Coronavirus Dispatch: Tycoon running 500 hotels cautions of more job cuts

Popular posts

  • I.O.I: Where Are They Now?
  • What Mahatma Gandhi Can Teach Qantas and Other Businesses about Customer Service
  • Navigating Recessionary Headwinds by Driving Efficiency in the Back Office
  • Understanding the Fundamentals of Real Estate Investing: Insights from Sam Primm
  • Quixotic Design Co.: Driving Women-Owned Businesses to the Top of Their Industries

Popular Tags

American Benefits brand Business business tips career coach covid-19 digital marketing economy employee Entrepreneur entrepreneurship featured finance Health inflation influencer investment Investor job leadership marketing Medical School mentor mentorship money News pandemic personal development plan recession Residency retirement small business social media sponsored startup strategy success tax technology tips work workplace
ADVERTISEMENT
  • About
  • Free Mentorship
  • Show Your Support
  • Become a Contributor
  • Apply As Guest
  • Listen on Apple
  • Listen on Spotify
Mentors Collective Success Magazine

Owned by Otter Love LLC

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Business
  • Self Growth
  • Mentors Collective Podcast
    • Apply As Guest
    • Listen on Spotify
    • Listen on Apple

Owned by Otter Love LLC

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
Go to mobile version